Why Startups (and Tesla) Will Struggle with Electric Pick Ups

MEDICALJMP

Well-known member
First Name
Jeff
Joined
Apr 28, 2020
Messages
687
Reaction score
1,148
Location
Omaha, NE
Vehicles
Toyota Avalon, Rav4, Tri-motor Cybertruck
Occupation
Nurse
Country flag
I know where my money (literally) is bet. As I am sure most of you will disagree with the presenter. What are your thoughts after listening?

_————————————————————————-


Why Startups (and Tesla) Will Struggle With Electric Pickups
The competition here is like nothing else.
By John Rosevear
February 7, 2021

How will Tesla's (NASDAQ: TSLA) Cybertruck fare against Detroit's huge-selling pickups? In this Motley Fool Live broadcast, recorded on Jan. 12, Industry Focus host Nick Sciple and Fool.com senior auto specialist John Rosevear explained why they see pickup trucks as an important trend for auto investors to follow in 2021 -- and why Tesla and other new entrants will have a tough time in this hugely profitable market segment.

A transcript is below the video.

Nick Sciple: John, what's your last trend for cars for 2021?

John Rosevear: It's a trend that we can talk about every year, really. But I want to talk about it mostly so that folks remember that it's still here. Americans buy a lot of pickup trucks, a lot of pickup trucks. These are the best-selling vehicles in America, and they held up surprisingly well through 2021. We had factory shutdowns, and people sheltering at home, sheltering in place during the height of the pandemic earlier in the year, the first height of the pandemic. But Ford (NYSE:F) and General Motors (NYSE:GM) still sold a lot of pickups, Fiat Chrysler too, in 2020.

These are massively important, massively profitable products. They will go electric in time, Ford and GM have already made it pretty clear that those things are coming soon. In fact, Ford has said they'll have it out and about a year-and-a-half, an electric F-150. But there's this whole ecosystem around pickups and commercial vehicles and so forth, where they're modified by companies called upfitters that adapt them for commercial fleet uses, for specific tasks and so forth.


This is a huge, huge business. It's a huge market. It's immensely profitable. That is not going to change, I don't think, as we move to electric vehicles, and people should remember that.

Americans buy a lot of pickup trucks, and 20 years from now, maybe they'll be buying a lot of electric F-150. But this market is here to stay, and it is a huge driver of profit for General Motors, Fiat Chrysler, the company that is merging with Peugeot to become Stellantis (NYSE:STLA). For these three companies, in particular -- Toyota (NYSE:TM) has an incremental presence with a few other smaller players -- this is big bucks. This is -- for a company like Ford, this is what's funding the EV revolution, F-150's and Super Duty [pickup trucks]. Investors should remember that and watch this market. Because this market, if Detroit defends anything, it's going to be pickups and commercial vehicles. I think new entrants are going to find vigorous resistance and vigorous competition as they try to enter it, and I think many investors downplay that, and don't realize how big that is.

Nick Sciple: Yeah. I was going to your point, John, around maybe stickiness of truck sales is just for autos across the board, whether it's if you're a Tesla owner, or if you're someone who likes Corvettes or Jeeps or whatever, there's this identity that people have with their cars. Once you become an F-150 person or you're a truck guy, it's hard to get you off being a truck guy, and I think a lot of people know that these type of people will just in their everyday life.

If you look around and see that just to put some numbers which you said earlier, so this is from a 2019 Barclays estimate was in the Wall Street Journal. Truck sales have historically counted for around 70 percent of Ford's global profit and around half of GM's global profits. So absolutely, I mean, this is the lifeblood of the business. This is where the earnings are coming from.

Then lastly, just to look at the size of this sales lines. The F-series has been the top-selling pickup truck in the US for more than 40 years. Part of that is the F-Series is under one label. Actually, this year, GM outsold Ford in there with the Silverado and GMC Sierra just by a little bit. On the numbers for these vehicles, 787,422 Ford F-Series sold in the year 2020, and that was down 12 percent year-over-year, just to give you context. There's just some massive sales of this vehicle. Tesla in 2020 had a record year, around half a million vehicles.

I mean, there are shares in this market that are really, really significant. Two ways to think about that is Tesla has a big hill to climb to overcome the scale thing, or you could interpret it as this is a whole bunch of market share to go gobble up as they push in trying to take profits with Cybertruck and things like that. We'll just see how they are able to execute. But any last thoughts, John, on this pickup market, and I want to take these last 15 minutes or so to answer whatever questions folks have. I'm sure folks have a lot.

John Rosevear: Just wanted to say one thing which is that Ford sold 787,000 pickups in 2020, despite the fact that their factories were down not only during the COVID disruption, but because they were changing over to the all-new truck which began shipping at the very end of November, the all-new F-150. Which required, I mean, they estimate they lost something like 60,000 units of production as they switched over their factories to make the new truck. The last time we saw GM lead was when Ford was switching over to the last new F-150 in 2015. These are monster products and it's where you really see -- particularly Ford -- throw everything it knows and everything it has into every new truck. It's why they continue to do so well here, and it will be a daunting task for anybody who thinks they're going to try to disrupt this.


John Rosevear owns shares of Ford and General Motors. Nick Sciple has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Tesla. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.





Advertisement

 

EMguy

Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2021
Messages
9
Reaction score
16
Location
USA
Vehicles
Cybertruck AWD
Country flag
I own tesla stock because I think they will continue to grow, but I agree with the authors that Tesla's growth will be limited by legacy automakers snatching up a significant portion of EV sales. Tesla has a couple more years without significant competition, and then people will start to have choices when buying EVs.

I do not think tesla will come anywhere close to beating out Ford in the truck market in the foreseeable future. The F-series has been the best selling vehicle for over 40 years.

I placed a Cybertruck reservation not because I prefer it over a Ford, but simply because it was the best option at the time. If Ford can produce an electric F150 with good range and decent price, I will gladly cancel my reservation and buy the Ford. I like the Cybertruck, but I would prefer something made by a legacy automaker.

Don't underestimate the millions of loyal Ford and GM buyers. We like having buttons and dashboard gauges. We like getting our vehicles serviced the old fashioned way at a dealer or shop of our choosing. We like being able to rapidly obtain any part needed from a dealer, Amazon, or local retailer. We like the quality control generally provided by legacy auto makers. We like to be able to adjust the temp in our vehicles without navigating a touchscreen. We like having a large variety of colors, trim levels, and options to choose from.

If Ford or GM puts a competitively priced truck on dealer lots sometime in 2022 or 2023, I think a lot of people will jump ship from the Cybertruck to something else.

In the meantime, I'll continue to hold my Tesla shares and watch them grow.
 

Jhodgesatmb

Well-known member
First Name
Jack
Joined
Dec 1, 2019
Messages
896
Reaction score
926
Location
San Francisco Bay area
Vehicles
Lexus Rx450H Tesla Model 3
Occupation
Researcher
Country flag
I was raised in Michigan and my father worked for Ford until I was in high school. Granted that was a long time ago but my memories are still strong of a company that pushed innovation away and cared more about planned obsolescence so that they could sell cars than on quality. Perhaps Ford has changed in the intervening years, but brand loyalty goes both ways; when you lose the faith it is gone. Because f this I just have a hard time believing that Ford will try to build an awesome EV. My gut tells me that they will slap an EV powertrain onto their existing design and count on their reputation and buyer laziness to carry them forward. I do agree that Tesla will run out of lead in a couple of years but I do not think that Elon Musk is worried about that; he wants to see the world using EVs and the legacy automakers have to be a big part of that equation. What it will do for me is that I will probably not invest in more Tesla stock and just see how what I do own fares.
 

Diehard

Well-known member
First Name
D
Joined
Dec 5, 2020
Messages
317
Reaction score
503
Location
U.S.A.
Vehicles
Oldsmobile Aurora V8, Saturn Sky redline, Nissan Frontier,...
Country flag
My bias against or for a brand has some impact on my decision but value by far has the most impact on my choice. I think Tesla is gunning for that as well. That is something that traditional design and manufacturing process may have problem competing against. I like mechanical systems more than electronics but if CT is $20K less than the competition, there are not enough buttons to keep me away.

Value, expected ease and cost of ownership, charging network and purchase process being the same, they all would be a fair game for me.
 

Dids

Well-known member
First Name
Les
Joined
Dec 21, 2019
Messages
948
Reaction score
1,714
Location
Massachusetts
Vehicles
04 Tacoma, 21 Cybertruck
Occupation
Self
Country flag
I own tesla stock because I think they will continue to grow, but I agree with the authors that Tesla's growth will be limited by legacy automakers snatching up a significant portion of EV sales. Tesla has a couple more years without significant competition, and then people will start to have choices when buying EVs.

I do not think tesla will come anywhere close to beating out Ford in the truck market in the foreseeable future. The F-series has been the best selling vehicle for over 40 years.

I placed a Cybertruck reservation not because I prefer it over a Ford, but simply because it was the best option at the time. If Ford can produce an electric F150 with good range and decent price, I will gladly cancel my reservation and buy the Ford. I like the Cybertruck, but I would prefer something made by a legacy automaker.

Don't underestimate the millions of loyal Ford and GM buyers. We like having buttons and dashboard gauges. We like getting our vehicles serviced the old fashioned way at a dealer or shop of our choosing. We like being able to rapidly obtain any part needed from a dealer, Amazon, or local retailer. We like the quality control generally provided by legacy auto makers. We like to be able to adjust the temp in our vehicles without navigating a touchscreen. We like having a large variety of colors, trim levels, and options to choose from.

If Ford or GM puts a competitively priced truck on dealer lots sometime in 2022 or 2023, I think a lot of people will jump ship from the Cybertruck to something else.

In the meantime, I'll continue to hold my Tesla shares and watch them grow.
When would you buy an electric f150? The first year? Or would you wait to see if they got it right? Later after the bev fudsters have had a chance to distort perception of it? Is legacy automaker reputation outweighing Tesla legacy bev maker reputation? Which do you trust?
You say you like to choose where you get service... do you really, its kinda like saying you like to choose your dentist? Wouldn't you prefer no service and choose the most convenient, lowest cost, highest quality service? Probably yes so is it really that you like the choice or that you want to escape being trapped by mediocre service.
You say you like buttons and knobs... my phone has 3 buttons and all 3 annoy me. Does your phone still have a keyboard? Why did you choose to upgrade from the buttons? It is possible that you still have a flip phone but I doubt that someone who would pre order a CT still uses one.
Please don't think I'm being harsh or nosey, I am genuinely interested in your answers because I have never understood brand loyalty, people describe me as a pod person, which I take to mean they think I integrate and not that I'm a vegetable, hopefully.
 
Last edited:
First Name
James
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
8
Reaction score
14
Location
Euless, Tx
Vehicles
Model 3, F150, Sorento
Occupation
Retired
Country flag
I have no doubt that Ford can build a good electric truck with decent range. But they will not have a charging network like Tesla. That is the biggest reason I have ordered the CT. Tesla also has several advantages like having built EVs since 2012 and OTA updates.
As far as buttons, have you looked at new cars/trucks recently? You will see that the charge to screens and larger screens has already started. Buttons will soon be a thing of the past. And unscheduled service is mainly driven by all the sensors that an ICE vehicle has to have for emissions/mileage. I just had a large expensive internal part of my F150 transmission replaced because it failed.
 

EMguy

Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2021
Messages
9
Reaction score
16
Location
USA
Vehicles
Cybertruck AWD
Country flag
When would you buy an electric f150? The first year? Or would you wait to see if they got it right? Later after the bev fudsters have had a chance to distort perception of it? Is legacy automaker reputation outweighing Tesla legacy bev maker reputation? Which do you trust?
You say you like to choose where you get service... do you really, its kinda like saying you like to choose your dentist? Wouldn't you prefer no service and choose the most convenient, lowest cost, highest quality service? Probably yes so is it really that you like the choice or that you want to escape being trapped by mediocre service.
You say you like buttons and knobs... my phone has 3 buttons and all 3 annoy me. Does your phone still have a keyboard? Why did you choose to upgrade from the buttons? It is possible that you still have a flip phone but I doubt that someone who would pre order a CT still uses one.
Please don't think I'm being harsh or nosey, I am genuinely interested in your answers because I have never understood brand loyalty, people describe me as a pod person, which I take to mean they think I integrate and not that I'm a vegetable, hopefully.
I'll respond to a couple of questions. I don't meant to ignore any of them... There are just too many to address on one post typed on a phone keyboard.

When would I buy the F150? The very first year. I will buy the first electric truck I can get my hands on if it meets my needs and preferences. I need good range, features, and options at a price that seems reasonable to me.

Legacy reputation definitely outweighs Tesla reputation for me. They have a reputation of making quality vehicles without quality control issues. Sure... There are exceptions to this, but it's generally true.

As far as service, of course I prefer to not need it. That's not possible with any vehicle. Overall it seems it's much easier to find a Ford or GM service center within a few miles than a Tesla service center. I can also get almost any Ford or GM part same day or have it shipped to me in a few days. It can take months to get certain Tesla parts or have some services completed as far as I can tell. I've never owned a Tesla. I'm basing this on experiences Tesla owners post online and state on Youtube regarding service and parts. The mobile service seems convenient when available, but there are some repairs that require a service center or parts which can be hard to get. People sometimes wait months to get the problems fixed that were present the day their Teslas rolled off the assembly lines.

My phone does not have a keyboard... But that's ok because I don't need to navigate menus or open apps on my phone easily while driving at the same time. Nobody can say it's rational to require drivers to navigate a touchscreen while driving to adjust vents and climate control.

I'm not loyal to one specific brand. I just choose a vehicle based on the totality of its features.

If the Ford and GM EV trucks cost a fortune or lack some needed functionality the Cybertruck provides, I will take the Cybertruck.

I just think it would take a lot for me to give up having regular dashboard gauges and physical buttons for the most common functions in a vehicle. I also have a hard time looking last the quality control issues that plagued the Model 3 and Model Y. I didn't reserve a Cybertruck the day it was revealed, so thankfully I will be able to assess the quality issue with Cybertruck prior to making a purchase. I'll give Tesla the benefit of the doubt for now on Cybertruck build issues that may or may not occur, but we will see what happens.
 
Last edited:

EMguy

Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2021
Messages
9
Reaction score
16
Location
USA
Vehicles
Cybertruck AWD
Country flag
I have no doubt that Ford can build a good electric truck with decent range. But they will not have a charging network like Tesla. That is the biggest reason I have ordered the CT. Tesla also has several advantages like having built EVs since 2012 and OTA updates.
As far as buttons, have you looked at new cars/trucks recently? You will see that the charge to screens and larger screens has already started. Buttons will soon be a thing of the past. And unscheduled service is mainly driven by all the sensors that an ICE vehicle has to have for emissions/mileage. I just had a large expensive internal part of my F150 transmission replaced because it failed.
I have a 2020 vehicle with a large screen. It still has a physical volume knob, climate control buttons, windshield wiper buttons, sunroof buttons, and so on. Those types of functions are duplicated in the large touchscreen, but I haven't seen any evidence that they are being chased out any time soon by anyone other than tesla.

It may not be a big deal for some people, but it matters to most of us. This is a Tesla forum, so there will be some sampling bias. Most people want buttons for the common stuff.

I agree that the charging network is a Tesla advantage. I'm not sure how long that will last though... At least several more years for sure.

The legacy automakers are focusing on buying or partnering with the large charging networks in order to provide some sort of semi homegrown charging networks. I think it will take years for those to grow enough to compare to the Tesla charging network, and there are no guarantees it will happen. I think the charging networks will grow EV after EV sales continue to grow, so there will likely be a shortage of chargers for a while if cars like the Mach E sell faster than expected.
 
Last edited:
First Name
James
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
8
Reaction score
14
Location
Euless, Tx
Vehicles
Model 3, F150, Sorento
Occupation
Retired
Country flag
I have found that the voice commands replace the buttons you so desire. I can change temperature and seat heater by pushing the button (icon) that's always visible on the screen or using voice commands activated by the button on the steering wheel. On the Tesla forums there is a listing of the voice commands which gets longer with every OTA update.. Media volume and muting and selection of the next song is accomplished with the button on the left side of the steering wheel. Adjustments to mirrors, steering wheel and seats should not be done while moving anyway.
Oh both my Teslas have memories for such things so when I enter it's all set for me and likewise my wife. It recognizes us by our phones.
 

BillyGee

Well-known member
First Name
Bill
Joined
Jan 22, 2020
Messages
209
Reaction score
316
Location
Northern California
Vehicles
F350, Yamaha Stryker
Occupation
Technician
Country flag
What are these guys even talking about? They realize this is on the internet forever so that we can quote them being this wrong and bold about their fud in 20 years, right?

Is this the same Ford and GM that were showing off electric sedans in the 90s and have nothing to show for it? The same Ford that benched all their EV projects until Tesla showed up? The same Crysler that discarded their turbine engine in the 60s because it "polluted too much", even though it could be run on tequila?

I just want to be sure, because I'm only 32 and I've been hearing from legacy automakers about how EVs are the future since I was cognisant, but I've yet to see any of them actually create an electric car worth a damn. Suddenly someone comes along and shows it's viable and the entire defense force shows up to phone it in.

I'm a truck guy, I've had several, I drive one every day to job sites and use it for moving machines and tools where I need them and I can't wait for my cybertruck. The people that buy trucks for status should be a moot point, they always follow downstream of the economic sector that uses them most.

Dollar for dollar an EV truck makes nothing but sense for businesses, and once they become normalized I can guarantee that you're going to see this aftermarket support and every ugly clip in grill you can imagine. Truck culture is a thing, but it's something that has changed and evolved with the times, not some cornerstone of Americana that never changes.
 
Last edited:

gphenix

Member
First Name
Gary
Joined
Sep 3, 2020
Messages
16
Reaction score
36
Location
Canyon, Texas
Vehicles
75th Anniversary Jeep Grand Cherokee, MERCEDES AMG SLC43
Country flag
I’m buying electric because I am tired of my ICE vehicles depreciating as soon as I drive it off the lot. I am tired of paying for fluid, oil and tranny fluid so it will last longer. Guess what the longer it lasts makes it worth less, I’m ready to try something else. This is why I chose the Cybertruck.
 

flowerlandfilms

Well-known member
First Name
Eryk
Joined
Dec 6, 2020
Messages
66
Reaction score
118
Location
Australia
Vehicles
Yamaha SRV-250
Occupation
Film Maker
Country flag
...Tesla has also never run itself into the ground...
...taken a huge government bailout...
...used that tax payer money for bonuses to executives...
...and gone right back to stagnant product lines...
...running themselves into the ground yet again...
...I think that's going to factor into "brand loyalty"...
 

Crissa

Well-known member
First Name
Crissa
Joined
Jul 8, 2020
Messages
3,037
Reaction score
3,205
Location
Santa Cruz
Vehicles
2014 Zero S, 2013 Mazda 3
Country flag
Motley Fool is a scam that pretends it has insider information and leads that into paying subscriptions.

Notice this article doesn't say the change in sales for GM this year; only Ford. So the numbers are meaningless and incomparable. They say nothing, and pretends it means something.

More, they act as though there is some sort of inevitability to numbers that already exist. But there is not. If one product is cheaper, it'll sell more. If one is better, it might sell more. If it's advertised a little better, it might sell more... But that only changes it a little.

Suggesting that entirely new platforms with backorders equal to any one model of the established players' shows an inherent weakness to the established brands. If their win was inevitable, you wouldn't see that.

If Ford or GM puts a competitively priced truck on dealer lots sometime in 2022 or 2023, I think a lot of people will jump ship from the Cybertruck to something else.
But they won't. Nor will their EV production be a tenth of Tesla's. That's the problem.

-Crissa
 
Last edited:

Advertisement





 


Advertisement
Top